Version 1[]
- Timmy as Mordecai
- Mort (from Madagascar) as Rigby
- Timmy's Dad as Benson
- Vitaly (from Madagascar) as Skips
- King Julien (from Madagascar) as Muscle Man
- Maurice (from Madagascar) as Hi-Five Ghost
- Melman (from Madagascar) as Pops
- Gloria (from Madagascar) as Margaret
- Marlene (from Madagascar) as Eileen
- Gia (from Madagascar) as Audrey
Version 2 (created by AskSuzette101)[]
- Timmy as Mordecai
- Chester as Rigby
- Aj as Benson
- Chloe as Margaret
- Tootie as Eileen
Version 3[]
- Timmy as Mordecai
- Chester as Rigby
- Aj as Benson
- PC Mackintosh (from Wallace and Gromit) as Skips
- Mr. Turner as Pops
- Mark Chang as Muscle Man
- Lady Tottington (From Wallace and Gromit) as Margaret
- Fluffles (From Wallace and Gromit) as Eileen
- Feathers McGraw (From Wallace and Gromit) as Were Skunk
- Victor Quartermaine (from Wallace and Gromit) as Evil Taxi
- Reverend Clement Hedges (from Wallace and Gromit) as High Five Ghost
- Mr. Mulch (from Wallace and Gromit) as Thomas
- Mrs. Mulch (from Wallace and Gromit) as Audrey
- Were-Rabbit (from Wallace and Gromit) as Destroyer of Worlds
Version 4 (created by Wigguy12)[]
- Timmy as Mordecai
- Trixie as Margaret
- Chester as Rigby
- AJ as Pops
- Brick (from The Powerpuff Girls (1998)) as Carrey O'Key
- Boomer and Butch (from The Powerpuff Girls (1998)) as Carl