Cast[]
- Peter Pan as Numbuh 1
- John Darling as Numbuh 2
- Tinker Bell as Numbuh 3
- Michael Darling as Numbuh 4
- Tiger Lily as Numbuh 5
- Wendy Darling as Numbuh 362
- Slightly as Numbuh 60
- Cubby as Numbuh 65.3
- The Twins as Numbuh 44 Twins
- Nibs as Tommy Gilligan
- Tootles as Joey Beatles
- George Darling as Monty Uno/Numbuh Zero
- Mary Darling as Mrs. Uno/Numbuh 999
- The Blonde Mermaid as Henrietta Von Marzipan
- The Red-Head Mermaid as Numbuh 10
- The Brunette Mermaid as Katie
- The Indian Chief as Maurice/Numbuh 9
- Squaw as Cree Lincoln
- Mr. Smee as Dumb John Silver
- Captain James Hook as Stickybeard