Cast[]
- Twilight Sparkle as Peter Pan
- Fluttershy as Wendy Darling
- Rarity as John Darling
- Pinkie Pie as Michael Darling
- Shining Armor as Mr. George Darling
- Princess Cadence as Mrs. Mary Darling
- Rainbow Dash as Tinkerbell
- Spike as Nana and Nana II
- Discord as Captain James Hook
- Starlight Glimmer as Mr. Smee
- Legion of Doom and Changelings as Pirates
- Steven Magnet as Tick-Tock Crocodile
- Scootaloo as Slightly
- Apple Bloom as Nibs
- Snips and Snails as The Twins
- Sweetie Belle as Cubby
- Pipsqueak as Tootles
- Chief Thunderhooves as The Indian Chief
- Little Strongheart as Tiger Lily
- Winter Lotus as Squaw
- Other Ponies as Other Indians
- Seaponies and Hippogriffs as Mermaids
- Applejack as Edward
- Trixie as Jane
- Dinky Doo as Danny