Cast[]
- Elmo as Cinderella
- Zoe as Prince Charming
- Oscar the Grouch as Lady Tremaine
- Ernie as Anistasia
- Bert as Drizella
- Grover as The Fairy Godmother
- Rosita as The King
- Prairie Dawn as Prudence
- Julia as Jaq
- Abby Cadabby as Gus
- Elizabeth as The Grand Duke
- Betty Lou as Bishop
- Little Murray Sparkles as Lucifer
- Roxie Marie as Herald
- Various Female Sesame Street Muppets as Royal Guards
- Telly Monster as The Queen
- Sesame Street Birds as Birds