Thread:AStranger195/@comment-3388044-20150731200407/@comment-4632631-20150801034445

Nah, I'm just gonna continue using their recommendation at the Signature Guide page, which is this:

COCW sig
Pros:
 * 1) Works with my COCW sig
 * 2) Allows me to type just three tildes instead of four

Cons:
 * 1) parameter is unneeded for my non-COCW sig
 * 2) My signature is SUBSTituted, therefore it'll show the code on the pages I sign on
 * 3) Uses w:c:clashofclans:User:AStranger195/Sig

Wikia Guestbook sig
Pros:
 * 1) My favorite, I like the design
 * 2) Links to my guestbook, which is what Wikia Guestbook is for
 * 3) Recommended on the main page of Wikia Guestbook

Cons:
 * 1) I need to type four tildes
 * 2) Incompatible with my COCW sig
 * 3) SUBSTituted
 * 4) Uses w:c:guestbook:User:AStranger195/Sig

Global sig
Pros:
 * 1) Simple design
 * 2) Links to my contributions page, unlike others
 * 3) Links to my guestbook, unlike my COCW sig
 * 4) Talk link works in wikias where user talk pages are used in favor of Message Walls (e.g. old abandoned wikias)

Cons:
 * 1) Frequently updated, therefore hard to update on all wikias
 * 2) SUBSTituted
 * 3) Complex code
 * 4) Incompatible with my COCW sig

Conclusion

 * COCW sig: $$2 pros - 3 cons = -1$$
 * Wikia Guestbook sig: $$3 pros - 4 cons = -1$$
 * Community Central: $$4 pros - 4 cons = 0$$

Well, 0 is higher than -1, so I'll continue using my current COCW-compliant code.