Character Mix/Old Bad Polly (from Muppet Sing-Alongs: Muppet Treasure Island)

Cast

 * Baby Gonzo (from Muppet Babies) as Polly Lobster
 * Tigger (from Winnie the Pooh) as Murray the Minstrel
 * Garden Green (from Crayola Markers) as Walleye Pike
 * Pineapple Shooting Star (from Mr. Sketch Markers) as One-Eyed Jack