My Little Pony/Sweeney Todd

Pinkie Pie as Sweeney Todd

Rarity as Nellie Lovett

Sunset Shimmer as Judge Turpin

Applejack as the Beadle

Flash Sentry as Anthony

Twilight Sparkle as Johanna

Surprise as Lucy

Pipsqueak as Toby

Prince Blueblood as Pirelli