Between the Lions, Muppet Treasure Island and Melissa and Doug Puppets/For the Longest Time (by Billy Joel)

Cast

 * Theo (from Between the Lions) as Billy Joel
 * Barnacle Bart (from Melissa and Doug Puppets), Lionel (from Between the Lions), Clueless Morgan (from Muppet Treasure Island), Polly Lobster (from Muppet Treasure Island) and Smoulder the Dragon Puppet (from Melissa and Doug Puppets) as Billy's High School Friends
 * King Puppet (from Melissa and Doug Puppets) as The Janitor