Thread:BiggestThomasFan/@comment-24362609-20170613141841/@comment-1338865-20170613154305

Well, roles in Thomas/TUGS videos that I don't mind include (and this only goes to ones I've actually seen in videos on YouTube):
 * Donald/Douglas as Big Mac
 * Edward as OJ
 * Gordon as Top Hat
 * Murdoch as Hercules
 * Arry as Zebedee
 * Bert as Zak
 * Duck as Grampus
 * Bertie as Grampus
 * Harold as Grampus (Why do you hate it? I don't think it's a bad choice since they both travel a different way from the engines and tugs)
 * Toad as Izzy Gomez
 * Rosie as Lillie Lightship
 * Lady as Sally Seaplane
 * Bulgy as Boomer (Both were finally happy after a change; Bulgy being a vegetable bus and Boomer being a houseboat)
 * Oliver as Billy Shoepack
 * Toad as Lord Stinker
 * Bill and Ben as Frank and Eddie
 * Duke as Old Rusty
 * Freddie as Old Rusty
 * Cranky as Jack the Grappler

Ideas I don't like? Well, I don't like most of the ones you listed either, but the ones that I never liked include:
 * Mr. Percival as Captain Zero (I think some people only used this because Mr. Percival was the only one left from the TV Series who usually is in charge. However, we have Sailor John now, and he seems much better for Zero)
 * Gordon as Bluenose (Gordon maybe pompous, but Bluenose is hated by both the Star tugs and Z-Stacks)
 * James as Johnny Cuba (I think I've heard of a user who said he'd use this. And although I respected his opinion, I still don't like this idea)
 * Skarloey and Rheneas as Burke and Blair (Does anyone know why this has been used in some videos?)
 * Freddie and Duke as Burke and Blair