Character Mix/Real Pirate (from Muppet Sing-Alongs: Muppet Treasure Island)

Cast

 * Chunk Squarey (from Rolie Polie Olie) as Kermit the Frog
 * Patrick Star (from SpongeBob SquarePants) as Clueless Morgan
 * Mr. Small (from The Mr. Men Show) as Polly Lobster
 * O the Owl (from Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood) as Mad Monty
 * Doc McStuffins (from Doc McStuffins) as Girl Pirate
 * Winnie the Pooh (from Winnie the Pooh) as Old Tom
 * Oscar Grouchy Green (from Sesame Street Crayons) as Mudwell the Mudbunny
 * Oobi (from Oobi) as Calico
 * Caillou (from Caillou) as Murray the Minstrel
 * Super Why (from Super Why!) as Walleye Pike
 * Hundley (from Curious George) as One-Eyed Jack
 * Barney (from Barney and Friends) as Black Dog
 * Boober Fraggle (from Fraggle Rock) as Spotted Dick
 * Little Bird (from Sesame Street) as Seagull