Thread:BiggestThomasFan/@comment-24362609-20170711152522/@comment-24362609-20170711162639

Also, here's my list of Top 35 Worst Thomas Episodes: Dishonouralbe mentions: Henry and the Wishing Tree, Thomas, Emily and the Snowplough, Emily's Adventure, You Can Do it Toby!, Rheneas and the Dinosaur, Toby Feels Left Out, Thomas' Tricky Tree, Wharf and Peace, Thomas and the Big Bang, Edward and the Mail, Skarloey Storms Through, The Party Surprise, Duncan and the Hot Air Balloon, The Lion of Sodor, Slippy Sodor, Thomas and the Pigs, Toby's New Whistle, Thomas and the Runaway Kite, Thomas' Tall Friend, Toby and the Whistling Woods, Pop Goes Thomas, Percy's New Friends, Kevin the Steamie, Percy the Snowman and Thomas Toots the Crows
 * 1) Buzzy Bees
 * 2) Ho Ho Snowman
 * 3) Fiery Flynn
 * 4) Sodor Surprise Day
 * 5) James to the Rescue
 * 6) Race to the Rescue
 * 7) The Other Side of the Mountain
 * 8) Time for a Story
 * 9) Thomas and the Snowman Party
 * 10) Thomas' Frosty Friend (No, just no...)
 * 11) Wonky Whistle
 * 12) Push Me Pull You (worst narrow-gauge episode ever)
 * 13) The Christmas Tree Express
 * Up, Up and Away
 * 1) Skarloey the Brave
 * 2) Middle Engine
 * 3) Chickens to School
 * 4) The Early Bird
 * 5) Edward Strikes Out
 * 6) Toby's Truimph
 * 7) Henry's Magic Box
 * 8) Topped Off Thomas (Thomas calling the wind Mr. Wind? Also, why didn't Sir Topham Hatt just buy a new top hat after his old one blew away?)
 * 9) Snow
 * 10) Don't Be Silly Billy
 * 11) Toby's Discovery
 * 12) Henry Gets it Wrong
 * 13) Charlie and Eddie
 * 14) The Green Controller
 * 15) Henry and the Flagpole
 * 16) Ol' Wheezy Wobbles
 * 17) Smoke and Mirrors
 * 18) Thomas' Milkshake Muddle
 * 19) Percy's Big Mistake
 * 20) The Frozen Turntable
 * 21) Rocky Rescue

And my list of Top 35 Debatable Episodes is the same as yours, so I won't bother with the official list, but here are the honourable mentions: Horrid Lorry, Rusty Saves the Day (I do agree that it does seem unlikely that Sir Topham Hatt would close down the Skarloey Railway, but the moral about working together was good), The Grand Opening, Spic and Span, Thomas and the Toyshop, Thomas and the Birthday Picnic (Though, I might call it a favourite of mine sometime soon), Tuneful Toots, Emily Knows Best, Bold and Brave, Follow That Flour, Seeing the Sights, Thomas and the Treasure, Henry's Lucky Day, Thomas Sets Sail, Percy and the Left Luggage, Toby's Special Surprise, Tram Trouble, Don't Go Back, The Man in the Hills, Double Trouble, Playtime, Splish Splash Splosh!, Hiro Helps Out, Big Belle, Emily's Winter Party Special, Muddy Matters, Signals Crossed, Timothy and the Rainbow Truck, Salty All at Sea and Engine of the Future

So, you can obviously tell me what's different between my lists and yours can't you? Though seeing as you've done redeemable versions of Toby's Discovery and Snow, and are planning to redeem Middle Engine (along with Wharf and Peace, Thomas and the Big Bang and The Early Bird) for your eighth and final fan-made season, would it be safe to assume that as Rusty Saves the Day is from the classic series (Seasons 1-7), you should give it another watch just be sure what you think about the moral and reconsider your thoughts on the episode? Hopefully that should give you some ideas for when you extend the best, worst and debatable episode galleries from Top 35 to Top 40 in September.