101 Dalmatians/Peter Pan

Cast

 * Pongo as Peter Pan
 * Perdita as Wendy
 * Lucky as John
 * Patch as Michael
 * Lucy as Tinkerbell
 * Cruella De Vil as Captain Hook (Cruella and Captain Hook are both the main antagonist of each movie. Despite having different genders)
 * Horace as Mr. Smee
 * Scar (from The Lion King) as Tick-Tock the Crocodile
 * Rolley as Cubby
 * Sgt. Tibbs as Slightly
 * Skippy (from Robin Hood) as Nibs
 * Toby (from Robin Hood) as Tootles
 * Napoleon & Lafayette (from The Aristocats) as The Twins
 * Roger as Indian Chief
 * Andita as Tiger Lily
 * George Banks (from Mary Poppins) as George Darling
 * Winifred Banks (from Mary Poppins) as Mary Darling