Homestar Runner - Avenue Q

The Internet

 * Marzipan - Kate


 * The KoT - Trekkie Monster


 * Strong Bad - Rod


 * Coach Z - Brian


 * Strong Sad - Gary


 * Homestar - Princeton

BA in English/It Sucks to Be Me

 * Bubs - Princeton


 * Marzipan - Kate


 * Reynold - Brian


 * Eh! Steve! - Rod


 * Strong Sad - Nicky


 * Strong Bad - Gary


 * The Ugly One - Christmas Eve

If You Were Gay

 * Gunhaver - Nicky


 * Reynold - Rod

Schadenfreude

 * Strong Bad - Gary


 * Homestar - Nicky