Thread:BiggestThomasFan/@comment-24362609-20160411154948/@comment-1338865-20160411175049

Yes. That's what I trying to do when I originally posted it; taking the concept of Henry and the Wishing Tree, and try to get right what it got wrong. Also, I would think that Goodbye Fat Controller (from Season 19) would be Percy's Big Mistake done right, and I posted an episode idea on a separate page for one that's Edward Strikes Out done right. It's called James and Rocky. The point of that was to try to give Rocky a better introduction. Also, I can't really see how Middle Engine and The Green Controller would be redeemable. I mean, Push Me, Pull You maybe, but the other two? Not so sure.

And finally, about the DIY episode and the motion picture episode you requested, are you sure you don't want to post them on a page for your own episode ideas? It might be a bit better if you just created a page for your own ideas. Yes or no, have you considered creating a page like that at all? Not trying to be rude, but I thought you might like to try that sort of thing.