Character Mix/Sailing for Adventure (from Muppet Treasure Island)

Cast

 * Jeremy Johnson (from Phineas and Ferb), The Amazing Mumford (from Sesame Street), Zoe Zingy Orange (from Sesame Street Crayons), Tico the Squirrel (from Dora the Explorer), Guy Smiley (from Sesame Street), James (from Thomas and Friends), Chunk Squarey (from Rolie Polie Olie) and Ord (from Dragon Tales) as The Pirates
 * The Count Batty Black (from Sesame Street Crayons) as Sam the Eagle/Samuel Arrow
 * Bert (from Sesame Street) as Fozzie Bear/Young Squire Trelawney
 * Scooter (from The Muppets) as Gonzo
 * Chuck E. Cheese (from Chuck E. Cheese) as Rizzo the Rat
 * Hamilton Hocks (from Maggie and the Ferocious Beast) as Polly Lobster
 * Baby Bear Beary Brown (from Sesame Street Crayons) as Clueless Morgan
 * Pa Gorg (from Fraggle Rock) as Mad Monty
 * Maurice Monster (from Sesame Street), Bear (from Bear in the Big Blue House), Baby Kermit (from Muppet Babies), Mailbox (from Blue's Clues), Rowlf the Dog (from The Muppets), Kermit the Frog (from The Muppets), Candace Flynn (from Phineas and Ferb), Amaya (from PJ Masks), Roosevelt Franklin (from Sesame Street), Prince James (from Sofia the First), Owl (from Winnie the Pooh), Big Bird Feather Yellow (from Sesame Street Crayons), Yogi Bear (from Yogi Bear), Janice (from The Muppets), King Roland II (from Sofia the First), Baby Rowlf (from Muppet Babies), Kate Monster (from Avenue Q), Trekkie Monster (from Avenue Q), Gobo Fraggle (from Fraggle Rock) and Excuse Moi! (from Muppet nail polish) as Rats
 * Princess Baldegunde (from Phineas and Ferb) as Donna Plagueman
 * Clifford (from Clifford the Big Red Dog) and Clifford (from The Muppets) as Statler and Waldorf
 * Basil (from Johnny and the Sprites) as Jim Hawkins
 * Mini Magenta (from Crayola Markers) as Long John Silver