Thread:BiggestThomasFan/@comment-24362609-20171114165713

As you now think Rusty Saves the Day is the worst episode of the Classic series, and other bad episodes from that series have a better chance of redemption (like Toby's Discovery, Snow and Middle Engine), I wanted to know if Toby and the Flood was going to have a chance of being redeemed if I were to do that sort of episode for my fan-made series. I mean, if I were to do that, which would best for the improved version, the Skarloey engines, the Culdee Fell Railway or the Arlesdale Railway? Though would you say TATF was pretty bad but still watchable, or just either terrible or awful? 