Character Mix/The Magic Store (from The Muppet Movie)

Cast

 * Ricky (from Avenue Q) as Kermit the Frog
 * Kate Monster (from Avenue Q) as Miss Piggy
 * Riff (from Barney and Friends) as Fozzie Bear
 * King Roland II (from Sofia the First) as Gonzo
 * Gobo Fraggle (from Fraggle Rock) as Rowlf the Dog
 * Furline Huskie (from Sesame Street) as Scooter
 * Behemoth (from The Muppets) as Dr. Teeth
 * Thig (from The Great Santa Claus Switch) as Animal
 * Owl (from Winnie the Pooh) as Floyd Pepper
 * Gwen (from Johnny and the Sprites) as Janice
 * Mr. Small (from The Mr. Men Show) as Zoot
 * Gil (from The Muppets Take Manhattan) as Dr. Bunsen Honeydew
 * Clifford (from Clifford the Big Red Dog) as Beaker
 * Emma (from Ready, Steady, Wiggle!) as Camilla the Chicken
 * Pixel (from LazyTown) as Sweetums
 * Bobby Benson (from The Muppets) as Robin the Frog
 * Oswald (from Oswald) as Statler
 * Hoots the Owl (from Sesame Street) as Waldorf
 * Trekkie Monster (from Avenue Q) as Sam the Eagle
 * Bubba (from The Muppets) as Lew Zealand
 * Jeremy Johnson (from Phineas and Ferb) as The Swedish Chef
 * Mr. Brown (from Chuck E. Cheese) as Crazy Harry
 * Clover (from Sofia the First) as Doglion
 * Snuffy (from Sesame Street) as Marvin Suggs
 * Zach (from Saved by the Bell) as Big Bird
 * Clueless Morgan (from Muppet Treasure Island) as Link Hogthrob
 * Jim (from The Muppet Show) as Fletcher Bird
 * Chocolate Mint (from Mr. Sketch Markers) as Mean Mama
 * Greg (from PJ Masks) as Luncheon Counter Monster
 * Roo (from Winnie the Pooh) as Boppity
 * Jackman Wolf (from Sesame Street) as Baskerville the Hound
 * Colambo (from Sesame Street) as Nigel the Conductor
 * Benny Rabbit (from Sesame Street), Jenny Brown (from Phineas and Ferb), Enzo (from Sesame Street), Mr. Bounce (from The Mr. Men Show) and Tigger (from Winnie the Pooh) as Pigs
 * Izzy (from Sesame Street episode 4029) as Oscar the Grouch
 * Eeyore (from Winnie the Pooh) as Bert
 * Ryan Evans (from High School Musical) as Ernie
 * Mr. Munch (from Chuck E. Cheese) as Cookie Monster
 * Bear (from Bear in the Big Blue House) as Grover
 * Alice (from Alice in Wonderland) as Prairie Dawn
 * Baileywick (from Sofia the First) as Count von Count
 * Rizzo the Rat (from The Muppets) as Herry Monster
 * Jasper T. Jowls (from Chuck E. Cheese) as Biff
 * Placido Flamingo (from Sesame Street) as Sully
 * Patrick Star and Mr. Krabs (from SpongeBob SquarePants) as Two-Headed Monster
 * Jake (from Jake and the Never Land Pirates) as Sherlock Hemlock
 * Iver (from The Hoobs) as Guy Smiley
 * Don Music (from Sesame Street) as Little Bird
 * Baby Scooter (from Muppet Babies) as Farley
 * Hundley (from Curious George) as Roosevelt Franklin
 * Cinderella (from Cinderella) as Roosevelt Franklin's Mother
 * Beauregard (from The Muppets) as Herbert Birdsfoot
 * Ronnie Trash (from Sesame Street) as Mr. Johnson
 * Baljeet (from Phineas and Ferb) as Maurice Monster
 * Jack Bauer Muppet (from Sesame Street) as Harvey Monster
 * Convincing John (from Fraggle Rock) as Thomas Twiddlebug
 * Elsa (from Frozen) as Tessie Twiddlebug
 * Tigger (from Winnie the Pooh) as Bruce Monster
 * Sofia (from Sofia the First) as Cousin Monster
 * Chunk Squarey (from Rolie Polie Olie) as Brad
 * Tally Otter (from Bear in the Big Blue House) as Georgie (Sesame Street)
 * BJ (from Barney and Friends) as Blue AM Kid
 * Penny (from The Big Bang Theory) as Afghan Hound
 * Amelia (from Sesame Street episode 2223) as Alice Otter
 * Horatio the Elephant (from Sesame Street), Benny the Bat (from Bear in the Big Blue House), Daphne (from Scooby-Doo), Moss (from Bear in the Big Blue House), Prince James (from Sofia the First), Leona (from Between the Lions), Robby the Seal (from Pingu), Vanessa Doofenshmirtz (from Phineas and Ferb), Periwinkle (from Blue's Clues), Flo Bear (from Sesame Street), J.G. Frackle (from The Muppets), Gabriella Montez (from High School Musical), Moving Boxes (from Avenue Q), Bruce Monster (from Sesame Street) and The Newcomer (from Avenue Q) as Anything Muppets
 * George the Janitor (from The Muppets), Mike (from Mike the Knight) and Peg (from Peg + Cat) as Baby Band
 * Ramone (from Peg + Cat), Biscuit Monster (from The Furchester Hotel), Curly Bear (from Sesame Street) and The Royal Barber (from Sesame Street) as Baby Koozebanian Creatures
 * Harvey P. Dull (from The Furchester Hotel) as Beauregard
 * Scooter McNutty (from Barney and Friends) as Beautiful Day Monster
 * Crossing Guard (from Elmo's World: Helping) as Beaver
 * Treelo (from Bear in the Big Blue House) as Behemoth
 * Luther O'Possum (from Sesame Street) as Billy the Bear
 * Accordion (from Elmo's World: Music) as Brewster
 * Fern (from Crayola Colors) as Brown Bat
 * The Kindly Giant (from Maggie and the Ferocious Beast) as Bubba
 * Pammy (from Getting Ready to Read) as Catgut
 * Pint Sized Purple (from Crayola Markers) as Chick
 * Bicycle (from Elmo's World: Bicycles), ???? and Little Miss Whoops (from The Mr. Men Show) as Chickens
 * Blue-Violet (from Crayola Colors) as Chuck Stoat
 * Diva D'Abruzzo (from Elmo's World: Singing) as Cow
 * BB Cats (from Maggie and the Ferocious Beast) as Crocodile
 * Steve's Grandmother (from Blue's Clues) as Mildred Huxtetter
 * Doc Hogg (from Bear in the Big Blue House) as Fred Lizard
 * Roxie Marie (from Sesame Street) as Queen Peuta
 * Grover (from Sesame Street) as Scred
 * Red Fraggle (from Fraggle Rock) as Zelda Rose
 * Apple (from Mr. Sketch Markers) as Vazh
 * Baby Bear Beary Brown (from Sesame Street Crayons) as Emmet Otter
 * Book (from Elmo's World: Getting Dressed) as Wendell Porcupine
 * Football (from Elmo's World: Balls), Ferb Fletcher (from Phineas and Ferb), Nina (from Imagination Movers), Pasqually (from Chuck E. Cheese) and Leslie Mostly (from Sesame Street) as Frogs
 * Stephanie (from LazyTown) as Gladys