Blindly Selected HGTV Characters/Muppet Treasure Island

Cast

 * Greg Brady (from A Very Brady Renovation) as Polly Lobster


 * Marcia Brady (from A Very Brady Renovation) as Clueless Morgan


 * Peter Brady (from A Very Brady Renovation) as Mad Monty


 * Jan Brady (from A Very Brady Renovation) as Angel Marie


 * Bobby Brady (from A Very Brady Renovation) as One-Eyed Jack


 * Cindy Brady (from A Very Brady Renovation) as Old Tom


 * Jonathan Scott (from Property Brothers) as Blind Pew


 * Drew Scott (from Property Brothers) as Walleye Pike


 * Mina Starsiak (from Good Bones) as Spotted Dick


 * Karen E. Laine (from Good Bones) as Black Dog


 * Leanne Ford (from Restored by the Fords) as Calico


 * Jasmine Roth (from Hidden Potential) as Jacques Roach


 * Lara Spencer (from Flea Market Flip) as Real Old Tom


 * Stephen Rotondaro (from Simply Quilts) as Long John Silver


 * Ed Christie (from Simply Quilts) as Dead Tom


 * Connie Peterson (from Simply Quilts) as Headless Bill


 * Barbara Davis (from Simply Quilts) as Mudwell the Mudbunny


 * Carol Binion (from Simply Quilts) as Big-Fat-Ugly-Bug-Face-Baby-Eating O'Brien